Gifts Beyond the Ordinary

Smoochin’ Under the Mistletoe

Series: Families and Heroes Collection, Book 2

Written by Madison Love

Release Date: 12.01.25

Genre: Christian Romance, Christmas

4 Stars!

Not every Christmas looks like the one we planned. Sometimes the year ends not with wishes granted, but with the ache of loss and the mess of dreams undone. Smoochin’ Under the Mistletoe is a story that meets us in that place and gently leads us toward something richer: a holiday where grace, kindness, and the steady hand of God are the truest gifts of all.

Lucy’s Christmas is nothing like she imagined. Instead of the ring and promises she hoped for, her world unravels: a heartbreak, a diner lost, and the kind of disappointment that stings deep. But the heart of her small town beats with the kind of love that never stands far off. In the comfort of her neighbors, the wisdom of those who’ve walked hard roads, and a faith that shows up in action, Lucy finds hope again.

I especially loved how the Christmas story itself is freshly considered through the eyes of Lucy’s community. This year, the Christmas Eve Service is about seeing “the roles that others played in the story and how there are lessons that apply to our daily lives—not just during the holidays.” That gentle nudge to look deeper is woven throughout Lucy’s own journey.

There’s a scene where comfort arrives not just in words, but in presence: “He doesn’t expect us to carry our burdens alone. He’s there for us, and we are to lean on Him during those difficult times and when strugglin’. You have all of us as well. We’re here to help even when you don’t ask for it.” It’s the kind of kindness that makes a community feel like family, even on the loneliest days.

And at the heart of the story is a love that’s willing to weather storms and disappointment, trusting in God’s plan, but also knowing that “those plans require faith and action on our part.” With that kind of faith and with someone by your side who truly cares … anything can be overcome.

Madison Love writes with warmth and truth, wrapping faith and romance together like a favorite Christmas quilt. This story is gentle but unmistakable in its message: we are never alone, and sometimes the greatest miracles come in the form of second chances and the quiet strength to begin again.

I am eager to read more from this author. Her stories shine with grace, hope, and the reminder that even in seasons of loss, Christmas is still a story of Christ’s amazing love.

I received a digital ARC of this book from the author via Book Sirens. I am not required to write a positive review nor paid to do so. This is my honest and unbiased review. My thoughts and opinions expressed in this book review are my own. My review focuses on the writing and story’s content, ensuring transparency and reliability.